Cookies Survive, Privacy Sandbox Doesn’t: Was It All a Five-Year Detour?

cookies remain on google chrome

Share This Post

Last Friday Google retired most of Privacy Sandbox. Topics, Protected Audience, Attribution Reporting, IP Protection and a handful of others are all being shut down, with Google pointing to low adoption. A few pieces survive, like CHIPS and FedCM, mostly because other browsers decided they liked them too. Back in April, Google had already said third-party cookies would stay in Chrome. So that’s that. The cookie apocalypse the whole industry spent half a decade preparing for isn’t coming.

I’ll Go First

In January of last year we wrote that Google was turning off cookies for millions of browser users, and that April we told Advertisers the time was now to get Enhanced Conversions in place before Chrome finished the job that summer. Google did start that test with 1% of Chrome users. It just never finished the job. Three months after our post, Google switched to a “user choice” plan, and this spring it dropped even that.

So, we were wrong on the timeline and wrong on the outcome. I’d rather say that out loud than pretend we saw it coming. To be fair to ourselves, so was pretty much everyone, including Google, which announced in January 2020 that cookies would be gone from Chrome within two years and then pushed the date back three separate times.

Why It Died

Nobody wanted what Google was building. Advertisers and ad tech companies ran their own tests on the Sandbox tools and kept reporting big drops in spend, clicks and performance compared to cookies. Publishers worried about revenue. Regulators in the UK spent years asking whether the whole thing would just move more of the web’s ad data into Google’s hands, and that question got a lot louder once Google was found to be a monopolist in ad tech this past April.

I’ve always had my own version of that concern. Back when Google stopped passing referral data, we asked whether it was protecting privacy or hoarding data. Privacy Sandbox raised the same question on a much bigger scale. Taking away the third-party cookie hurts every ad platform except the one with billions of signed-in users. Google was never the one who needed cookies.

Was The Prep Work Wasted?

No. Cookies surviving in Chrome doesn’t put your measurement back where it was in 2019. Safari has been blocking third-party cookies for years, Firefox too. Apple’s App Tracking Transparency changed mobile tracking in 2021. Consent banners, ad blockers and shorter cookie lifespans have all chipped away at the signal along the way. Chrome is one browser. Your customers use several.

The accounts where we did that work, Enhanced Conversions first and then server-side tagging, offline imports and Meta’s Conversions API wherever the client could support it, are better off today than they would have been, cookie or no cookie. That work was recovering conversions that were already going missing. They also feed automated bidding a cleaner signal, and with Google pushing everyone toward more automation every year, that matters more than it ever did.

The one thing that really was wasted is the time people spent learning Topics and Protected Audience. If anyone on your team got deep into those, I’m sorry. That’s a few weeks you won’t get back, and I doubt Topics comes up in many job interviews from here on.

So, Do We Rip Anything Out?

Not a chance. I fully expect a client or two to ask whether they can switch off the server-side setup now that cookies are staying, and the answer is going to be no every single time. Cookies didn’t win here. The replacement lost. Everything else that was eating away at tracking, from Safari to consent banners, is still doing it, and if a first-party data project got shelved while everyone waited to see how this ended, it can come off the shelf. Today would be fine.

There is some short-term relief, to be fair. Third-party remarketing and cross-site frequency capping keep working in Chrome, which display-heavy accounts will appreciate. I just wouldn’t bet next year’s plan on it lasting. Google has changed its mind on this five times in five years, and if anything takes the cookie out for good now, my money is on privacy law and consent rules rather than a Chrome update.

Five years, three delays, one cancelled replacement, and the cookie is still sitting right where it was. The good news is that the work we did to stop depending on it still counts.

Update November, 2026: Google followed through on schedule—deprecating the retired Privacy Sandbox APIs in Chrome 144 (January 2026) and completing their removal from the browser in Chrome 150 (July 2026). Third-party cookies remain untouched in Chrome.

More To Explore

Want To Discuss How We Could Partner?

Let's have a chat