TikTok Is American Now. Is It Safe to Scale?

tiktok joint venture complete

Share This Post

TikTok’s new U.S. joint venture closed on January 22nd, and I’ll admit part of me didn’t believe it until the press releases actually went out. We’ve been through a federal law, a Supreme Court decision, deadline after deadline and more executive orders than most of us cared to keep track of. The new company even has a name that sounds like it came from a committee, TikTok USDS Joint Venture LLC. Oracle, Silver Lake and MGX lead the American ownership. ByteDance keeps a bit under 20%, Oracle hosts the U.S. data and the recommendation algorithm gets retrained on U.S. users.

And then the whole thing went down three days later. A weather-related power outage at an Oracle data center during the big storm, and for most of Sunday and into Monday people couldn’t post, view counts sat at zero and the For You page was serving up garbage. If anyone was looking for a sign, I’m not sure that was the one they wanted.

My opinion, and I know it isn’t the popular one this week: Don’t be in a hurry to pile money into TikTok. Just because the ban is off the table. Every one of those deadlines over the past two years meant another round of contingency planning for clients spending there, so believe me, I get the relief. But the ban was never the thing that made TikTok work or not work. The algorithm was. And the algorithm is the exact piece being torn up and retrained, by new people, on a smaller set of users.

Will it be better? Maybe. The cynic in me says a TikTok trained only on American users under American oversight starts to feel a little more like Instagram Reels, and I don’t mean that as a compliment. The optimist in me says a U.S.-only model might actually get sharper for U.S. Advertisers once it has a few months of data. I flip between the two depending on the day.

The odd part is the ad business itself isn’t moving. Ads, e-commerce and marketing stay with TikTok’s existing global business. The joint venture takes the data, the algorithm, moderation and security. So you’ll buy in the same Ads Manager from the same reps, but the system deciding who sees your ad answers to a different company. I’ve read half a dozen explainers on how that split works day to day. None of them actually answered it. If someone has a good one, send it my way.

This isn’t the first time I’ve watched a platform shift the ground under Advertisers. I wrote about LinkedIn pulling a bait and switch years ago. What stuck with me from that whole episode was how long it took people to stop comparing the new results to the old ones. Those old TikTok numbers in your reports are going to be tempting to lean on. I’d mostly ignore them for a while.

What I’d Actually Do With A TikTok Budget Right Now

Keep it about where it is. Pull your CPMs, CTR, cost per result and conversion rate from the last few months before the close. This way you have something to compare against, throw out the outage days because they’re junk, and then leave things alone for six or eight weeks. I go back and forth on whether that’s long enough. A retrained algorithm could keep settling for a lot longer than two months. But at some point you have to make a call, and that’s the window we’re using with our clients.

Look at your placements more often than you normally would, too. New moderation team, maybe new rules, and there were already people online claiming posts were being suppressed during the outage, which the joint venture denied. I don’t know who’s right there and I’m not going to pretend to. I’d just rather find out from a spot-check than from a client’s screenshot.

And if anyone’s wondering whether it’s worth the trouble at all, I’d point back to something from our post on Google’s antitrust ruling in 2024. Google’s own research had 63% of Gen Z using TikTok as a search engine. They didn’t go anywhere while the lawyers fought it out. They’re still there. The algorithm deciding whether they see you is what’s new.

Ask me again around March. I’ll have an actual opinion by then instead of a hunch.

More To Explore

Want To Discuss How We Could Partner?

Let's have a chat